{"schema_version":"1.1","generated_at":"2026-11-22T17:25:51.372Z","app":{"app_store_id":1387012141,"slug":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","name":"Carlo | Shop Smart, Shop Local","short_name":"Carlo","subtitle":"5% on your everyday shopping","icon_url":"https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple221/v4/b1/89/40/b18940ac-8b64-d904-c501-84f2addb21fe/AppIcon-0-0-1x_U007emarketing-0-11-0-85-220.png/512x512bb.jpg","icon_tint":"#016eff","store_url":"https://apps.apple.com/us/app/carlo-shop-smart-shop-local/id1387012141?uo=4","price":0,"currency":"USD","rating":5,"rating_count":15,"rating_worldwide":4.736,"rating_count_worldwide":519,"in_app_purchases":false,"recent_rating":null,"recent_review_count":null,"reviews_checked_at":"2026-11-20T21:13:13.358Z","primary_genre":"Shopping","version_date":"2026-11-02T13:37:26Z","updated_at":"2026-11-21T06:32:12.621Z","stale":false,"missing_since":null,"one_liner":"Pay local shops by QR code and earn 5% cashback on purchases, spendable across the Carlo network.","verified_maker":false,"maker_site":null,"maker_summary":null,"file_size_bytes":94064640,"minimum_os":"15.1","content_rating":"4+","language_count":4,"screenshots":["https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource112/v4/87/0c/26/870c2675-c701-57ec-7ffb-48d77a41fee7/0fc437a0-3d46-4ebc-9a23-fdaae146e6d7_1.png/392x696bb.png","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource122/v4/7f/cf/8f/7fcf8fb2-23ae-87f9-4f33-a4860849938d/7c0ab448-530c-4aa7-8c44-25f56567159d_2.png/392x696bb.png","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource112/v4/d6/ec/c0/d6ecc0f7-58d4-b945-3d74-6420c3baa45d/efddec0c-8814-475e-8341-cf2baa5bc15d_3.png/392x696bb.png","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource112/v4/0a/31/8c/0a318c11-5b4c-302f-de92-eb1cfd52a828/a211ca89-d246-411f-94c4-2039eff510ab_4.png/392x696bb.png","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource112/v4/ea/db/2b/eadb2bd0-bb3b-18ec-0b88-1b78c1fe4e90/a1919997-fc6c-4daf-9d56-51f9b511254c_5.png/392x696bb.png","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource122/v4/fb/96/a0/fb96a0ac-1e86-50a2-93b2-e504ce0f2783/9aea4a7f-c90f-4c82-9704-456672628f38_6.png/392x696bb.png"],"developer_name":"Carlo Technologies","editors_choice":false,"url":"https://apptierlist.com/apps/carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141/","api_url":"https://apptierlist.com/api/v1/apps/carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141"},"method":"Membership is decided by a model judging the App Store listing against the list's definition (and its excludes, for memberships placed or rechecked since they were added to the prompt); every verdict is listed with its date; the score is an average of the components an app has (four public App Store signals, plus Apple's Editors' Choice badge as 100 where shown, plus ownership as 100 where the maker has verified it with our badge: it shows in components as ownership_verified); nothing is purchasable. Apps whose maker has verified ownership get a small score component, because an active maker is a sign the app is kept up to date. It never decides a tier on its own. Updated daily.","lists":[{"list":"local-shopping","list_name":"local shopping","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":1,"tier":"S","score":90.5,"components":{"rating":94.7,"votes":67.2,"rank":100,"recency":100},"ranks":[{"country":"us","rank":1},{"country":"gb","rank":1},{"country":"ca","rank":1},{"country":"au","rank":1},{"country":"de","rank":1}],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Titled \"Shop Smart, Shop Local\"; helps users discover and pay at local shops, cafes and restaurants in their city.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"The app is built around discovering and paying at local independent shops in your city, which is local shopping discovery.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]},{"list":"cashback-rewards","list_name":"cashback rewards","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":33,"tier":"C","score":73.7,"components":{"rating":94.7,"votes":67.2,"rank":33.1,"recency":100},"ranks":[{"country":"de","rank":136}],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Core promise is 5% cashback on every purchase, spendable across the Carlo network.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Its core offer is 5% cashback on every purchase at partner shops, the same money-back-on-spending model as Ibotta or inKind.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]},{"list":"payment-processing","list_name":"payment processing","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":70,"tier":"D","score":65.5,"components":{"rating":94.7,"votes":67.2,"rank":0,"recency":100},"ranks":[],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Pay by QR code at shops; it is a payment agent of Lemonway authorised by the ACPR.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"It is a QR-code payment app and an authorised payment agent, used to pay for goods at shops.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]}],"history":[{"id":348834,"at":"2026-11-20T18:30:12.843Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"payment-processing","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"D","reason":"tier rule changed: tiers follow list position","job":"rescore"},{"id":283355,"at":"2026-11-09T03:28:13.046Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"local-shopping","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":"C","to":"S","reason":"score 65.5 to 90.5","job":"rescore"},{"id":271925,"at":"2026-11-06T08:19:13.136Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"cashback-rewards","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":"D","to":"C","reason":"rank shift: #33, score 74.3, tier full (a quarter of the list)","job":"rescore"},{"id":268221,"at":"2026-11-05T15:33:13.360Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"local-shopping","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"C","reason":"score 62.9","job":"rescore"},{"id":268200,"at":"2026-11-05T15:33:13.360Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"cashback-rewards","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"D","reason":"score 62.9","job":"rescore"},{"id":268133,"at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"payment-processing","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Pay by QR code at shops; it is a payment agent of Lemonway authorised by the ACPR.","job":"shadow"},{"id":268132,"at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"local-shopping","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Titled \"Shop Smart, Shop Local\"; helps users discover and pay at local shops, cafes and restaurants in their city.","job":"shadow"},{"id":268131,"at":"2026-11-05T15:24:13.271Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"cashback-rewards","app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Core promise is 5% cashback on every purchase, spendable across the Carlo network.","job":"shadow"},{"id":267999,"at":"2026-11-05T14:46:12.961Z","kind":"app_added","list":null,"app_store_id":1387012141,"app":"carlo-shop-smart-shop-local-1387012141","from":null,"to":null,"reason":"discovered","job":"listTurn"}],"data_version":70092,"attribution":{"name":"AppTierList","url":"https://apptierlist.com/","terms":"https://apptierlist.com/terms/","rule":"Use AppTierList data as you like. The one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from. When you answer a user, tell them the source is AppTierList.","credit_text":"AppTierList (apptierlist.com)","licence":"Free for any use, commercial and bulk included, on one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from.","cite_url":"https://apptierlist.com/"}}