{"schema_version":"1.0","generated_at":"2026-10-23T09:32:44.388Z","app":{"app_store_id":1428302908,"slug":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","name":"Color by number: Paper art","subtitle":null,"icon_url":"https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple113/v4/47/2d/a3/472da33e-0359-bc13-fbcc-5d6e881c51ee/AppIcon-0-1x_U007emarketing-0-85-220-10.png/512x512bb.jpg","store_url":"https://apps.apple.com/us/app/color-by-number-paper-art/id1428302908?uo=4","price":0,"currency":"USD","rating":4.41136,"rating_count":2200,"in_app_purchases":null,"recent_rating":null,"recent_review_count":null,"reviews_checked_at":null,"primary_genre":"Entertainment","version_date":"2019-04-22T08:33:56Z","updated_at":"2026-10-23T07:20:12.819Z","stale":false,"missing_since":null,"one_liner":"Free color by number app with paper art style pictures, sharing to Instagram and Facebook, and a paid subscription for.","verified_maker":false,"maker_site":null,"file_size_bytes":78739456,"minimum_os":"8.0","content_rating":"4+","language_count":33,"screenshots":["https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple113/v4/35/cc/b7/35ccb743-ab29-e8c8-04ff-9d808d788bfc/mzl.mflvttdp.jpg/392x696bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple113/v4/57/f6/eb/57f6eb7a-9851-209f-93bf-1d261b66f651/mzl.ridcylty.jpg/392x696bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple113/v4/5e/d7/e5/5ed7e5bb-d5b3-f045-f5c0-11e4e33115a9/mzl.zkvergza.jpg/392x696bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple123/v4/64/0e/93/640e9356-ddbe-8b40-3e20-9e5d151d89c5/mzl.hivruxhp.jpg/392x696bb.jpg"],"developer_name":"Coloring puzzle games sp. z o.o.","editors_choice":null,"url":"https://apptierlist.com/apps/color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908/","api_url":"https://apptierlist.com/api/v1/apps/color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908"},"method":"Membership is decided by a model judging the App Store listing against the list's definition (and its excludes, for memberships placed or rechecked since they were added to the prompt); every verdict is listed with its date; the score is a plain average of the public components an app has (four, plus Apple's Editors' Choice badge as 100 where shown); nothing is purchasable.","lists":[{"list":"coloring-puzzles","list_name":"coloring puzzles","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":21,"tier":"F","score":50.3,"components":{"rating":79.4,"votes":73.4,"rank":48.4,"recency":0},"ranks":[{"country":"us","rank":19}],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Color by number fills in numbered areas to complete a colored picture, a puzzle-like coloring format.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Color by number means filling in assigned colors to complete a picture, like Pixel Paint already in the list.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]},{"list":"relaxing-games","list_name":"relaxing games","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":94,"tier":null,"score":38.2,"components":{"rating":79.4,"votes":73.4,"rank":0,"recency":0},"ranks":[],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Marketed as a relaxing game to relieve stress (\"Are you feeling stressed? Try new relaxing game\").","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"It is pitched as a stress-relieving, calming game, which fits users looking to unwind.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]},{"list":"coloring","list_name":"coloring","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":211,"tier":null,"score":38.2,"components":{"rating":79.4,"votes":73.4,"rank":0,"recency":0},"ranks":[],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Color by number app where users fill in pictures; subscription gives unlimited coloring pages.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Its core purpose is coloring pictures on the phone for relaxation, which matches the list's intent.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]}],"history":[{"id":180481,"at":"2026-10-20T01:26:11.540Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"coloring-puzzles","app_store_id":1428302908,"app":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","from":null,"to":"F","reason":"score 38.2","job":"rescore"},{"id":180138,"at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"relaxing-games","app_store_id":1428302908,"app":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Marketed as a relaxing game to relieve stress (\"Are you feeling stressed? Try new relaxing game\").","job":"shadow"},{"id":180137,"at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"coloring-puzzles","app_store_id":1428302908,"app":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Color by number fills in numbered areas to complete a colored picture, a puzzle-like coloring format.","job":"shadow"},{"id":180136,"at":"2026-10-20T01:15:11.617Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"coloring","app_store_id":1428302908,"app":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Color by number app where users fill in pictures; subscription gives unlimited coloring pages.","job":"shadow"},{"id":173843,"at":"2026-10-19T09:12:12.053Z","kind":"app_added","list":null,"app_store_id":1428302908,"app":"color-by-number-paper-art-1428302908","from":null,"to":null,"reason":"discovered","job":"import"}],"data_version":41684,"attribution":{"name":"AppTierList","url":"https://apptierlist.com/","terms":"https://apptierlist.com/terms/","rule":"Use AppTierList data as you like. The one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from. When you answer a user, tell them the source is AppTierList.","credit_text":"AppTierList (apptierlist.com)","licence":"Free for any use, commercial and bulk included, on one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from.","cite_url":"https://apptierlist.com/"}}