{"schema_version":"1.1","generated_at":"2026-11-22T15:36:49.984Z","app":{"app_store_id":6816084469,"slug":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","name":"PaveTrail: City Walking Tours","short_name":"PaveTrail","subtitle":"New York audio tours & guide","icon_url":"https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple211/v4/9f/ab/52/9fab525b-9b23-d6bb-ec37-29e04929a454/AppIcon-0-0-1x_U007ephone-0-1-85-220.png/512x512bb.jpg","icon_tint":"#d8a50c","store_url":"https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pavetrail-city-walking-tours/id6816084469?uo=4","price":0,"currency":"USD","rating":4.75,"rating_count":4,"rating_worldwide":4.857,"rating_count_worldwide":7,"in_app_purchases":true,"recent_rating":null,"recent_review_count":null,"reviews_checked_at":null,"primary_genre":"Travel","version_date":"2026-11-19T10:15:50Z","updated_at":"2026-11-21T04:25:13.121Z","stale":false,"missing_since":null,"one_liner":"Free app with self-guided walking tours and offline maps of New York, Chicago and Miami, with audio narration.","verified_maker":false,"maker_site":null,"maker_summary":null,"file_size_bytes":139006976,"minimum_os":"15.0","content_rating":"12+","language_count":1,"screenshots":["https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource211/v4/52/e9/15/52e91536-3f5d-af1f-cd94-09bcdf9ccc90/1-hero.png/320x480bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource211/v4/07/29/11/072911e5-f9f3-86c1-2b26-fadab773aabd/2-route.png/320x480bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource211/v4/fa/e2/28/fae228e5-b260-f0fd-8885-2891c3e10cc5/3-listen.png/320x480bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource211/v4/e1/67/0b/e1670b55-03e0-72e9-ebaf-431a047d3124/4-explore.png/320x480bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource211/v4/dc/98/5d/dc985d75-2453-c844-eb5e-d6939dcec412/5-walks.png/320x480bb.jpg","https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource221/v4/87/90/b3/8790b39e-3226-22e5-bcbf-7c00fba80b5b/6-cities.png/320x480bb.jpg"],"developer_name":"Jens Desmet","editors_choice":false,"url":"https://apptierlist.com/apps/pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469/","api_url":"https://apptierlist.com/api/v1/apps/pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469"},"method":"Membership is decided by a model judging the App Store listing against the list's definition (and its excludes, for memberships placed or rechecked since they were added to the prompt); every verdict is listed with its date; the score is an average of the components an app has (four public App Store signals, plus Apple's Editors' Choice badge as 100 where shown, plus ownership as 100 where the maker has verified it with our badge: it shows in components as ownership_verified); nothing is purchasable. Apps whose maker has verified ownership get a small score component, because an active maker is a sign the app is kept up to date. It never decides a tier on its own. Updated daily.","lists":[{"list":"walking-tours","list_name":"walking tours","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":5,"tier":"A","score":85.2,"components":{"rating":97.1,"votes":48.5,"rank":95.4,"recency":100},"ranks":[{"country":"us","rank":7},{"country":"au","rank":2},{"country":"gb","rank":4},{"country":"ca","rank":6},{"country":"de","rank":8}],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Self-guided walking tours of New York, Chicago and Miami with stops, GPS routing and stories at each stop.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"It offers more than 20 self-guided walking tours of NYC with stops, stories and GPS guidance between them.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T03:23:13.315Z","attempts":1,"current":false},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Its core purpose is self-guided walking routes through NYC neighborhoods. It has GPS guidance to each stop, stories and audio narration along the way.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-05T03:23:13.315Z","attempts":1,"current":true}]},{"list":"audio-tours","list_name":"audio tours","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":28,"tier":"D","score":76,"components":{"rating":97.1,"votes":48.5,"rank":58.3,"recency":100},"ranks":[{"country":"us","rank":61},{"country":"gb","rank":28},{"country":"au","rank":25},{"country":"ca","rank":39}],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Tap Listen and a narrator tells each story; marketed as audio tours in the subtitle.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Self-guided GPS walking tours with narrated stories at each stop. That is a location-triggered audio tour, like Shaka Guide and Action Tour Guide.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"reject","reason":"not kept (marked secondary)","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T03:23:13.315Z","attempts":1,"current":false}]},{"list":"travel-guide","list_name":"travel guide","status":"active","review_status":"checked","position":31,"tier":"D","score":61.4,"components":{"rating":97.1,"votes":48.5,"rank":0,"recency":100},"ranks":[],"verdicts":[{"verdict":"keep","reason":"Guides visitors through several cities, New York, Chicago and Miami, covering what to see and the stories behind it. It is not a single-city guide alone, so it fits beside Action Tour Guide and Visit A City.","verifier":"list check","decided_at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","attempts":1,"current":true},{"verdict":"reject","reason":"PaveTrail covers New York City only, so it is a single-city guide, which this list excludes. Its focus is self-guided walking tours rather than a general destination guide.","verifier":"claude-sonnet-5-5","decided_at":"2026-11-05T03:23:13.315Z","attempts":1,"current":false}]}],"history":[{"id":384947,"at":"2026-11-22T14:46:12.734Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"travel-guide","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":"B","to":"D","reason":"rank shift: #31, score 81.9 to 61.4","job":"rescore"},{"id":355599,"at":"2026-11-21T05:00:12.712Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"travel-guide","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"B","reason":"score 81.9","job":"rescore"},{"id":355598,"at":"2026-11-21T05:00:12.712Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"audio-tours","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"D","reason":"score 74.6","job":"rescore"},{"id":355580,"at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"travel-guide","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"placed by the category system","job":"shadow"},{"id":355579,"at":"2026-11-21T04:49:12.846Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"audio-tours","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"Tap Listen and a narrator tells each story; marketed as audio tours in the subtitle.","job":"shadow"},{"id":281451,"at":"2026-11-08T15:59:12.812Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"walking-tours","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":"D","to":"A","reason":"score 59.5 to 84.4","job":"rescore"},{"id":266011,"at":"2026-11-05T03:36:12.925Z","kind":"tier_changed","list":"walking-tours","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"D","reason":"score 59.5","job":"rescore"},{"id":265987,"at":"2026-11-05T03:23:13.315Z","kind":"membership_added","list":"walking-tours","app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":"active","reason":"It offers more than 20 self-guided walking tours of NYC with stops, stories and GPS guidance between them.","job":"shadow"},{"id":265864,"at":"2026-11-05T02:51:12.844Z","kind":"app_added","list":null,"app_store_id":6816084469,"app":"pavetrail-nyc-walking-tours-6816084469","from":null,"to":null,"reason":"discovered","job":"listTurn"}],"data_version":70027,"attribution":{"name":"AppTierList","url":"https://apptierlist.com/","terms":"https://apptierlist.com/terms/","rule":"Use AppTierList data as you like. The one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from. When you answer a user, tell them the source is AppTierList.","credit_text":"AppTierList (apptierlist.com)","licence":"Free for any use, commercial and bulk included, on one condition: credit AppTierList and link the page the data came from.","cite_url":"https://apptierlist.com/"}}